Subject: Urgent: Restoring Harmony in Our Community
Dear NYU Administration,
For two decades, I have called your neighborhood home, living not just harmoniously, but in true friendship, amidst NYU's vibrant community of students and faculty. From spontaneous conversations in Think Coffee to chance encounters in Washington Square Park, my experiences with NYU community have always been enriching and deeply valued. However, a distressing situation compels me to write to you from a train, seeking refuge from what should be a sanctuary—my home.
The ongoing protest encampment, which has become the "ruler" of our New York City block is not only illegal, but dangerously disruptive and intimidating as their calls are NOT peaceful. This encroachment has severely impacted local residents and businesses and blatantly disregards city noise ordinances, particularly with nocturnal chants that disturb the peace and promote distressing rhetoric. These exact chants go straight into two children bedroom.
I too am an educator. Only just three weeks ago I had a very different stance on what was happening.
I saw students who wanted to be HEARD, so I went to listen and attempt dialogue. I stepped into the heart of the protest with a willingness to engage and understand, reflecting the educational spirit I thought we shared. Armed with knowledge of the protestors' demands, I sought a dialogue about the practical implications of their calls. Sadly, we only got to point number one before they branded me as an "agitator" on my own block and proceeded to encircle me with umbrellas.
As I walked away, they shouted "We speak to Zionist pigs."
Yesterday's encounter with a professor who labeled Israel an "apartheid state" and dismissed any raping or torture of Israelis on Oct 7th was BEYOND troubling. Not only was he misinformed, but when given a counter argument, he rolled his eyes and went back into the encampment (on public property that I am barred from). The behavior of faculty members raises serious concerns about the values of NYU and who it employs. It is with a heavy heart, as a staunch educator and protector of faculty rights, that I urge you to consider the immediate dismissal of those who forsake dialogue for dogma.
I am eager to discuss this further and share video evidence that underscores the urgent need for intervention. Let us work together to restore the integrity and safety of our shared community.
BUT let me be clear, my patience is gone. My children couldn't go to school today because I fear for the afternoons (will they shut down the street again?!). Getting my kids back into their house safely after school should not be a concern. They should also not be subjected to genocidal chants into their bedroom as they try to sleep.
Fix this immediately,
Abby Brody Once proud NYU neighbor
Atta girl!